i thought this book was cool along with the rest of the series and this book is were it all began and it really starts to pick up in the other books

I really like this book but what i didnt like was that when the older sister put on the mirror that they were being kidknapped the girl didnt believe her but other wise i liked the book.

Like i said for the other one this is were it really picks up and starts to really start with all of the other clans

this was the last book i read of this series and i hope to continue soon because i really like this series and its author Erin hunter did a great job