I like this book, the ending for me was a bit confusing, but the book was pretty good.

I love the Percy Jackson series. I saw the movie, they were both really good. I recommend it for 8 to 15 years old

My class and I read this book, it was amazing!!!! Esperanza has to learn how to rise above difficulties and adjust to being poor. I would really recommend this book. It is really interesting. When Papa, Sixto Ortega, was killed by bandits, Esperanza and Mama, Ramona Ortega, must escape from Tio Luis. Tio Luis was Papa's brother and wanted to marry Mama for wealth and respect. Mama, Esperanza, Miguel, Hortensia, and Alfonso escape at night to go to California. They stay at Alfonso's brother's house. Esperanza meets more people such as Marta, a girl that who despises Esperanza. There is a dust storm and Mama gets severely sick. Esperanza must learn to be the head of the household. (temporarily) This book is based on history, the Mexican Revolution, and the real Esperanza.( who is Pam Munoz Ryan's grandmother.

This book was really fun to read and was really great!!!

My class and I read this book. Karana faces many challenges and is really brave. I love her relationship with Rontu.